Dinner Menu | captainbills

We're not accepting online orders yet. Please contact us to complete the order.

Pickup, ASAP

Salads Appetizers Pierside Entrees Hearty Harbor Burger's & Sandwiches Children's Menu Sailor Sides Sweetwater Desserts

LUNCH MENU 11:30 am - 3 pm DINNER MENU 4 pm - Close Salads Appetizers Pierside Entrees Hearty Harbor Burger's & Sandwiches Children's Menu Sailor Sides Sweetwater Desserts

LUNCH MENU 11:30 am - 3 pm

Salads

Dressings: Country French, Ranch, Honey Mustard, Parmesan Peppercorn, House Balsamic Vinaigrette, Light Red Wine Vinaigrette, Thousand Island, Creamy Blue Cheese

Fresh Romaine Lettuce with seasoned croutons and aged parmesan cheese.

14.99 USD

A delicious blend of lobster and seafood with cucumber, mayo, scallions, fresh tarragon, lemon zest and cayenne pepper. Served on a bed of mixed greens with tomatoes, cucumbers, and red onion.

24.99 USD

This no-carbohydrate favorite includes romaine lettuce, baby greens, tomato, red onion, cucumber, with crumbly blue cheese, served with our house balsamic vinaigrette.

24.99 USD

Mixed greens, marinated chicken, with toasted almonds, pecans, tomato and red onion, finished with a sweet balsamic vinaigrette and topped with grilled apples, pecorino Romano and parmesan cheese.

22.99 USD

Grilled chicken on a fresh mix of chopped romaine and greens with our black bean, red onion,tomato, corn, and cilantro salsa with our chipotle BBQ ranch dressing.

22.99 USD

Fresh garden salad with kalamata olives, red onions, tomato cucumber, croutons and choice of dressing.

10.99 USD

Appetizers

Our famous New England clam chowder or our homemade soup of the day.

6.19 USD

Calamari lightly fried and served with remoulade and marinara sauce.

15.99 USD

Chilled tender shrimp served with our signature cocktail sauce.

15.99 USD

One pound of our tender mussels sautéed in scampi butter and white wine. Served with seasoned baguettes.

19.99 USD

Six delicious pork pot stickers with lemon poppy seed slaw and ponzu sauce.

15.99 USD

Hand wrapped shrimp in smoked bacon, deep fried and served with our remoulade sauce.

17.99 USD

Toasted Italian bread covered with a blend of diced tomatoes, garlic, basil, mozzarella cheese topped with our homemade balsamic vinaigrette.

12.99 USD

Fried golden crisp coconut shrimp. Served with boom boom sauce.

16.99 USD

A creamy blend of lobster, shrimp, artichokes, herbs and spices. Served with toasted garlic bread crisps.

19.99 USD

Two of our Maryland style crab cakes with succulent crab meat, vegetables and spices lightly fried and served with traditional tartar sauce.

19.99 USD

Delicious homemade buffalo chicken eggrolls served with blue cheese.

14.99 USD

Homemade lobster, black bean and cheese stuffed wonton lightly fried and served with an orange ginger citrus reduction.

17.99 USD

Pierside Entrees

Quarter–pound of tender shrimp, sautéed over linguini in our seafood alfredo sauce.

20.99 USD

A combination of shrimp, clams, and mussels sautéed in our signature pescatore red sauce or with our seafood alfredo sauce, served over linguini.

20.99 USD

A sirloin steak grilled to order brushed with herb & garlic butter.

24.99 USD

A half rack of fall off the bone St Louis pork ribs with Seneca Harbor's signature BBQ sauce.

24.99 USD

Marinated chicken breast over a bed of spinach topped with basil, tomato, fresh melted mozzarella cheese and drizzled with our balsamic sauce.

19.99 USD

Hearty Harbor Burger's & Sandwiches

Served with our homemade chips and a pickle.

Seneca Harbor hand made recipe of delicious crab and spices on a toasted hard roll with tartar sauce.

19.99 USD

Eight ounces of Angus beef, grilled & dressed with caramelized onions, bacon, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo and our sweet cabernet reduction served on a toasted hard roll.

19.99 USD

Add any topping to your cooked how you want it juicy 1/2 lb. Angus burger.

16.99 USD

Slow smoked pork piled high with our homemade barbeque sauce.

17.99 USD

Shaved Angus steak topped with grilled onions and melted swiss cheese on Italian Bread with au jus.

19.99 USD

Marinated mushroom cap topped with vegetables and mozzarella cheese on a ciabatta bread.

16.99 USD

Marinated chicken breast with lettuce & tomato on a toasted hard roll.

17.99 USD

Tomato, basil, mozzarella & spinach topped with our pesto mayo on a sun dried tomato wrap.

14.99 USD

Turkey & prosciutto with tomato, basil & mozzarella, on a bed of spinach topped with our pesto mayo on a sun dried tomato wrap.

17.99 USD

Corned Beef, swiss, Thousand island & sauerkraut on marbled rye.

18.99 USD

Crispy Beer battered Haddock, lettuce & tomato on toasted Italian bread with our homemade tartar sauce. Served with crinkle cut fries.

18.99 USD

Crispy beer battered Haddock served with french fries, coleslaw & our homemade tartar sauce.

20.99 USD

Toasted New England style roll stuffed with our homemade seafood salad.

18.99 USD

Children's Menu

All served with a side for our friends 10 and under.

14.99 USD

Sailor Sides

4.49 USD

5.49 USD

4.49 USD

Sweetwater Desserts

This one you MUST TRY, and is enough to share. Cream Puffs surrounded by a mountain of mascarpone and cream cheese sweetened with raspberries, topped with warm chocolate fudge with a touch of Chambord.

12.99 USD

Chocolate & peanut butter mousse with a chocolate cookie crust, topped with peanut butter drizzle & Reeses peanut butter cups.

9.99 USD

Warm chocolate bundt cake filled with a decadent chocolate ganache, served with vanilla ice cream.

10.49 USD

Creamy sweet and tangy lime filling topped with soft and fluffy whipped cream.

9.99 USD

Silky smooth and rich. Topped with strawberries if you like.

10.99 USD

Warm country style bread pudding loaded with white chocolate and cinnamon chips drizzled with our white chocolate glaze.

10.49 USD

Old-fashioned and timeless, our homemade classic recipe, loaded with apples and our buttery crisp topping.

9.99 USD

A dark chocolate flourless cake finished with a ganache topping.

9.99 USD

DINNER MENU 4 pm - Close

SALADS

Dressings: Country French, Ranch, Honey Mustard, Fat Free Raspberry Vinaigrette, Parmesan Peppercorn, Italian Vinaigrette, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Light Red Wine Vinaigrette, Thousand Island, Creamy Blue Cheese Crumbled Blue Cheese + $1.00

Fresh romaine lettuce with seasoned croutons and aged shredded parmesan cheese.

14.99 USD

A delicious blend of lobster and seafood with cucumber, mayo, scallions, fresh tarragon, lemon zest and cayenne pepper. Served on a bed of mixed greens with tomatoes, cucumbers, and red onion.

24.99 USD

This no-carbohydrate favorite includes romaine lettuce, baby greens, tomato, red onion, cucumber, with crumbly blue cheese, served with our house balsamic vinaigrette.

24.99 USD

Grilled chicken on a fresh mix of chopped romaine and greens with our black bean, red onion,tomato, corn, and cilantro salsa with our chipotle BBQ ranch dressing.

22.99 USD

Mixed greens, marinated chicken, with toasted almonds, pecans, tomato and red onion, finished with a sweet balsamic vinaigrette and topped with grilled apples, pecorino Romano and parmesan cheese.

22.99 USD

Fresh garden salad with kalamata olives, red onions, tomato cucumber, croutons and choice of dressing.

10.99 USD

Appetizers

Our famous New England clam chowder or our homemade soup of the day.

6.19 USD

Flour dusted calamari lightly fried and served with marinara and garlic butter.

15.99 USD

Chilled tender shrimp served with our signature cocktail sauce.

15.99 USD

One pound of our tender mussels sautéed in scampi butter and white wine. Served with seasoned baguettes.

19.99 USD

Six delicious pork pot stickers with lemon poppy seed slaw and ponzu sauce.

15.99 USD

Hand wrapped shrimp in smoked bacon, deep fried and served with our remoulade sauce.

17.99 USD

Toasted Italian bread covered with a blend of diced tomatoes, garlic, basil, mozzarella cheese topped with our homemade balsamic vinaigrette.

12.99 USD

Fried golden crisp coconut shrimp. Served with boom boom sauce.

16.99 USD

A creamy blend of lobster, shrimp, artichokes, herbs and spices. Served with toasted garlic bread crisps.

19.99 USD

Two of our Maryland style crab cakes with succulent crab meat, vegetables and spices lightly fried and served with traditional tartar sauce.

19.99 USD

Delicious homemade buffalo chicken eggrolls served with blue cheese.

14.99 USD

Homemade lobster, black bean and cheese stuffed wonton lightly fried and served with an orange ginger citrus reduction.

17.99 USD

Boatsman's Grill

Served with fresh baked Italian bread and one side. Make your side a premium mushroom, or sweet potato side for an additional .99

A half lb. sirloin steak with fresh herb butter and a handmade crab cake.

39.99 USD

A USDA half-pound filet grilled to order, topped with asparagus and our luscious lobster butter

49.99 USD

Our largest steak. This 20oz porterhouse grilled the way you like and brushed with our garlic herb butter.

49.99 USD

12oz Slow roasted Angus beef with our Seneca Lake red wine rub.

39.99 USD

A half lb. sirloin steak seasoned and topped with grilled shrimp, served with our fresh garlic herb butter.

35.99 USD

Our 3/4 lb. ribeye rubbed with a bold mix of chili's, espresso beans and a sweet cabernet reduction.

41.99 USD

Eight ounces of Angus beef, grilled & dressed with caramelized onions, bacon, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo and our sweet cabernet reduction served on a toasted hard roll.

24.99 USD

Two grilled caps filled with a blend of veggies and cheese served over sautéed spinach.

27.99 USD

Marinated chicken breast over a bed of spinach topped with basil, tomato, fresh melted mozzarella cheese and drizzled with our balsamic sauce.

29.99 USD

A rack of our slow cooked, fall off the bone St. Louis pork ribs with our Seneca Harbor signature BBQ sauce, or dry rub.

38.99 USD

A half rack of tender St. Louis ribs and grilled shrimp glazed with our Seneca Harbor signature BBQ sauce.

33.99 USD

A 12oz loin chop grilled to order and topped with a sweet chili sauce.

29.99 USD

Lakeside Pastas

Served with fresh baked Italian bread. Add garden salad for 4.99

Two-pound combination of shrimp, clams and mussels sautéed in our seafood Alfredo sauce with a hint of garlic, served over linguini.

34.99 USD

A combination of shrimp, clams, and mussels sautéed in our signature pescatore red sauce, served over linguini.

34.99 USD

Three quarter-pound of tender shrimp, sautéed in our seafood Alfredo sauce, served over linguini.

34.99 USD

Sweet lobster prepared in a creamy tabasco lobster sauce, over linguini.

34.99 USD

Creamy parmesan, mozzarella and asiago cheeses with lobster and cavatappi topped with two bacon wrapped shrimp.

34.99 USD

Rigatoni filled with Ricotta cheese, served with our own marinara sauce.

28.99 USD

Sautéed sweet peppers, broccoli, Kalamata olives, garlic, and hot peppers tossed in white wine and olive oil with penne pasta and feta cheese.

29.99 USD

Sautéed chicken, sweet peppers, broccoli, Kalamata olives, garlic, and hot peppers tossed in white wine and olive oil with penne pasta and feta cheese, may also order vegetarian.

29.99 USD

Sautéed chicken in a tomato, sherry cream sauce with roasted red peppers and a hint of pepperoni tossed with Rigatoni pasta.

28.99 USD

Tender hand breaded chicken breast, with our marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese, over linguine.

28.99 USD

Harbor Seafood Classics

Served with fresh baked Italian bread and one side. Make your side a premium mushroom, or sweet potato side for an additional .99

Grilled fresh salmon topped with rich buttery lobster, fresh tarragon and a dash of brandy.

36.99 USD

Fresh grilled salmon brushed with orange ginger glaze, or lightly seasoned with sea salt and black pepper.

33.99 USD

Our Maryland style crab cake lightly fried, shrimp, scallops and fish broiled in lemon and butter, served with traditional tartar and cocktail sauces.

39.99 USD

Three quarter pound fresh filet of haddock stuffed with lump crab topped with homemade lobster butter.

34.99 USD

Grilled boneless chicken breast with grilled shrimp skewers brushed with Thai sweet chili sauce and pineapple served over rice.

29.99 USD

Three of our Maryland style crab cakes made with succulent crab meat, vegetables and spices lightly fried. Served with traditional tartar sauce.

34.99 USD

Ten broiled shrimp scampi, five fried shrimp and five grilled shrimp served with rice and cocktail sauce.

33.99 USD

First Mate Children's Menu

All served with a side for our friends 10 and under

14.99 USD

Sailor Sides

4.49 USD

5.49 USD

6.49 USD

19.99 USD

11.99 USD

Sweetwater Desserts

12.99 USD

Chocolate & peanut butter mousse with a chocolate cookie crust, topped with peanut butter drizzle & Reeses peanut butter cups.

9.99 USD

Warm chocolate bundt cake filled with a decadent chocolate ganache, served with vanilla ice cream.

10.49 USD

Creamy sweet and tangy lime filling topped with soft and fluffy whipped cream.

9.99 USD

Silky smooth and rich. Topped with strawberries if you like.

10.99 USD

Warm country style bread pudding loaded with white chocolate and cinnamon chips drizzled with our white chocolate glaze.

10.49 USD

Old-fashioned and timeless, our homemade classic recipe, loaded with apples and our buttery crisp topping.

9.99 USD

A dark chocolate flourless cake finished with a ganache topping.

9.99 USD